Results | Experimental methods

R1 / C1 / I=4

Frame error rate

Figure (PDF)

Frame error rate

Figure (PDF)

Events: erroneous RS codewords for FER; criterion passes for timing. Intervals: at least 96% simultaneous per mode.

Original and added observations are combined once. Sample counts vary across points.

R1 / C1 / I=4 / AWGN

16428 air symbols; nominal duration 1.71125 s (waveform guards excluded).
Es/N0 [dB]C/N0 [dB-Hz]Original k / nAdded k / nTotal k / nFERLowerUpper
039.822765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.2540.072765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.540.322765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.7540.572765,472 / 65,5360 / 065,472 / 65,5360.99902340.99818750.9995518
140.822760,833 / 65,5360 / 060,833 / 65,5360.92823790.92254130.9336693
1.2541.072733,227 / 65,5360 / 033,227 / 65,5360.50700380.49622520.5177781
1.541.322713,362 / 65,5360 / 013,362 / 65,5360.20388790.19529520.2126641
1.7541.57279,678 / 65,5360 / 09,678 / 65,5360.14767460.14013610.1554313
241.82277,366 / 65,5360 / 07,366 / 65,5360.11239620.10570760.1193251
2.2542.07275,452 / 65,5360 / 05,452 / 65,5360.083190920.077366460.08927359
2.542.32274,241 / 65,5360 / 04,241 / 65,5360.064712520.059543580.07015114
2.7542.57273,097 / 65,5360 / 03,097 / 65,5360.047256470.042821930.05197148
342.82272,281 / 65,5360 / 02,281 / 65,5360.03480530.030997330.03890144
3.2543.07271,605 / 65,5360 / 01,605 / 65,5360.024490360.021304330.02797093
3.543.32271,171 / 65,5360 / 01,171 / 65,5360.017868040.015159960.02087474
3.7543.5727862 / 65,5360 / 0862 / 65,5360.013153080.010845750.01576192
443.8227580 / 65,536295 / 32,256875 / 97,7920.0089475620.0073766240.01072499
4.2544.0727400 / 65,536467 / 78,336867 / 143,8720.006026190.0049561110.00723923
4.544.3227252 / 65,536640 / 166,912892 / 232,4480.0038374170.0031595790.0046055
4.7544.5727163 / 65,536759 / 299,520922 / 365,0560.002525640.0020832110.003026504
544.8227118 / 65,536755 / 444,160873 / 509,6960.0017127860.0014033990.002064528
5.2545.072774 / 65,536777 / 759,808851 / 825,3440.0010310850.00084125380.001247497
5.545.322735 / 65,536161 / 251,648196 / 317,1840.00061793790.00040063360.0009023646
5.7545.572714 / 65,536288 / 750,848302 / 816,3840.0003699240.00026077230.0005059537
645.822713 / 65,536189 / 815,616202 / 881,1520.00022924540.00014857570.0003348672
6.2546.072711 / 65,536106 / 981,504117 / 1,047,0400.00011174366.226932e-050.0001823034
6.546.32275 / 65,5369 / 196,60814 / 262,1445.340576e-057.210203e-060.0001786247
6.7546.57272 / 65,53611 / 196,60813 / 262,1444.959106e-056.055558e-060.000172009
746.82271 / 65,5362 / 196,6083 / 262,1441.144409e-052.080819e-089.664488e-05
7.2547.07270 / 65,5363 / 196,6083 / 262,1441.144409e-052.080819e-089.664488e-05
7.547.32270 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05
7.7547.57270 / 65,5361 / 196,6081 / 262,1443.814697e-061.64201e-137.611759e-05
847.82270 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05

R1 / C1 / I=4 / Doppler

16428 air symbols; nominal duration 1.71125 s (waveform guards excluded).
Es/N0 [dB]C/N0 [dB-Hz]Original k / nAdded k / nTotal k / nFERLowerUpper
039.822765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.2540.072765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.540.322765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.7540.572765,492 / 65,5360 / 065,492 / 65,5360.99932860.9986060.9997442
140.822760,956 / 65,5360 / 060,956 / 65,5360.93011470.92448520.9354779
1.2541.072733,571 / 65,5360 / 033,571 / 65,5360.51225280.50147470.5230233
1.541.322713,615 / 65,5360 / 013,615 / 65,5360.20774840.19909390.216584
1.7541.57279,344 / 65,5360 / 09,344 / 65,5360.14257810.13515190.1502258
241.82277,420 / 65,5360 / 07,420 / 65,5360.11322020.10650950.1201705
2.2542.07275,479 / 65,5360 / 05,479 / 65,5360.083602910.077764950.08969883
2.542.32274,251 / 65,5360 / 04,251 / 65,5360.064865110.05969030.07030949
2.7542.57273,292 / 65,5360 / 03,292 / 65,5360.050231930.04566210.0550804
342.82272,339 / 65,5360 / 02,339 / 65,5360.035690310.0318340.03983424
3.2543.07271,650 / 65,5360 / 01,650 / 65,5360.0251770.02194560.02870253
3.543.32271,214 / 65,5360 / 01,214 / 65,5360.018524170.015764950.02158161
3.7543.5727859 / 65,5360 / 0859 / 65,5360.01310730.01080420.01571194
443.8227615 / 65,536213 / 26,368828 / 91,9040.0090094010.0073878020.01085025
4.2544.0727384 / 65,536518 / 84,480902 / 150,0160.0060126920.0049639380.007198742
4.544.3227240 / 65,536665 / 178,944905 / 244,4800.0037017340.0030517540.004437677
4.7544.5727188 / 65,536647 / 249,344835 / 314,8800.0026518040.0021663280.003204695
544.8227118 / 65,536767 / 444,160885 / 509,6960.0017363290.0014246860.002090326
5.2545.072758 / 65,536114 / 122,624172 / 188,1600.00091411560.0005766640.00136278
5.545.322737 / 65,536150 / 233,984187 / 299,5200.00062433230.00040049570.0009191158
5.7545.572724 / 65,536167 / 402,688191 / 468,2240.00040792440.00026211870.0005997695
645.822721 / 65,536125 / 471,808146 / 537,3440.00027170680.00016275460.0004209341
6.2546.07277 / 65,536189 / 1,602,816196 / 1,668,3520.00011748127.525933e-050.0001731381
6.546.32276 / 65,5369 / 196,60815 / 262,1445.722046e-058.43845e-060.0001851489
6.7546.57273 / 65,5365 / 196,6088 / 262,1443.051758e-051.616854e-060.0001371213
746.82270 / 65,5362 / 196,6082 / 262,1447.629395e-069.694379e-108.700967e-05
7.2547.07270 / 65,5364 / 196,6084 / 262,1441.525879e-051.053087e-070.0001055386
7.547.32270 / 65,5361 / 196,6081 / 262,1443.814697e-061.64201e-137.611759e-05
7.7547.57270 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05
847.82270 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05

R1 / C1 / I=4 / Doppler + jitter + echo

16428 air symbols; nominal duration 1.71125 s (waveform guards excluded).
Es/N0 [dB]C/N0 [dB-Hz]Original k / nAdded k / nTotal k / nFERLowerUpper
039.822765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.2540.072765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.540.322765,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.7540.572765,533 / 65,5360 / 065,533 / 65,5360.99995420.99962550.9999999
140.822765,036 / 65,5360 / 065,036 / 65,5360.99237060.99033950.9940968
1.2541.072757,537 / 65,5360 / 057,537 / 65,5360.87794490.87077140.8848844
1.541.322738,835 / 65,5360 / 038,835 / 65,5360.59257510.58195520.6031376
1.7541.572720,492 / 65,5360 / 020,492 / 65,5360.31268310.30274840.3227338
241.822712,068 / 65,5360 / 012,068 / 65,5360.18414310.17588590.1925959
2.2542.07278,935 / 65,5360 / 08,935 / 65,5360.13633730.1290530.1438469
2.542.32277,099 / 65,5360 / 07,099 / 65,5360.10832210.10174390.115143
2.7542.57275,527 / 65,5360 / 05,527 / 65,5360.084335330.078473460.0904547
342.82274,321 / 65,5360 / 04,321 / 65,5360.065933230.060717630.07141774
3.2543.07273,375 / 65,5360 / 03,375 / 65,5360.051498410.04687240.05640227
3.543.32272,590 / 65,5360 / 02,590 / 65,5360.039520260.035462130.04386365
3.7543.57271,813 / 65,5360 / 01,813 / 65,5360.027664180.024273750.03134721
443.82271,424 / 65,5360 / 01,424 / 65,5360.021728520.018732260.02502102
4.2544.0727997 / 65,5360 / 0997 / 65,5360.015213010.012722680.0180036
4.544.3227710 / 65,536157 / 13,568867 / 79,1040.010960250.0090354960.01313749
4.7544.5727512 / 65,536329 / 45,824841 / 111,3600.0075520830.0061979050.009088876
544.8227339 / 65,536586 / 105,472925 / 171,0080.0054091040.0044746310.006464672
5.2545.0727247 / 65,536642 / 171,776889 / 237,3120.0037461230.003083140.004497575
5.545.3227147 / 65,536847 / 340,480994 / 406,0160.0024481790.0020335130.002915569
5.7545.5727102 / 65,536860 / 527,104962 / 592,6400.0016232450.0013424290.001940665
645.822768 / 65,536950 / 835,0721,018 / 900,6080.0011303470.00093874020.001346375
6.2546.072749 / 65,536107 / 158,464156 / 224,0000.00069642860.00042788960.001058924
6.546.322730 / 65,536124 / 306,432154 / 371,9680.00041401410.00025242230.000633122
6.7546.572722 / 65,536113 / 446,720135 / 512,2560.00026354010.0001544490.0004148092
746.822710 / 65,536175 / 1,089,536185 / 1,155,0720.00016016320.00010144550.0002380708
7.2547.07275 / 65,5366 / 196,60811 / 262,1444.196167e-053.991467e-060.000158461
7.547.32273 / 65,53618 / 196,60821 / 262,1448.010864e-051.708995e-050.0002227741
7.7547.57271 / 65,5367 / 196,6088 / 262,1443.051758e-051.616854e-060.0001371213
847.82272 / 65,5363 / 196,6085 / 262,1441.907349e-052.945894e-070.0001139246