Results | Experimental methods

R2 / C1 / I=1

Frame error rate

Figure (PDF)

Frame error rate

Figure (PDF)

Events: erroneous RS codewords for FER; criterion passes for timing. Intervals: at least 96% simultaneous per mode.

Original and added observations are combined once. Sample counts vary across points.

R2 / C1 / I=1 / AWGN

4188 air symbols; nominal duration 0.218125 s (waveform guards excluded).
Es/N0 [dB]C/N0 [dB-Hz]Original k / nAdded k / nTotal k / nFERLowerUpper
042.833065,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.2543.083065,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.543.333065,498 / 65,5360 / 065,498 / 65,5360.99942020.99873630.9997973
0.7543.583064,713 / 65,5360 / 064,713 / 65,5360.9874420.98488840.9896938
143.833058,588 / 65,5360 / 058,588 / 65,5360.89398190.88722340.9004964
1.2544.083042,832 / 65,5360 / 042,832 / 65,5360.65356450.64326020.6637735
1.544.333024,740 / 65,5360 / 024,740 / 65,5360.37750240.36709130.3879895
1.7544.583014,406 / 65,5360 / 014,406 / 65,5360.21981810.21097830.2288316
244.83309,705 / 65,5360 / 09,705 / 65,5360.14808650.14053910.155852
2.2545.08307,245 / 65,5360 / 07,245 / 65,5360.11054990.10391090.1174302
2.545.33305,240 / 65,5360 / 05,240 / 65,5360.079956050.074239180.08593316
2.7545.58303,989 / 65,5360 / 03,989 / 65,5360.060867310.055848910.06615775
345.83302,785 / 65,5360 / 02,785 / 65,5360.042495730.038288260.04698661
3.2546.08302,063 / 65,5360 / 02,063 / 65,5360.031478880.027858910.03538908
3.546.33301,441 / 65,5360 / 01,441 / 65,5360.021987920.018973310.02529861
3.7546.5830976 / 65,5360 / 0976 / 65,5360.014892580.012429830.01765578
446.8330617 / 65,536273 / 26,112890 / 91,6480.0097110680.0080218010.01161987
4.2547.0830445 / 65,536445 / 63,232890 / 128,7680.0069116550.0057017450.008280443
4.547.3330279 / 65,536605 / 143,616884 / 209,1520.0042265910.0034781450.005074919
4.7547.5830173 / 65,536762 / 277,504935 / 343,0400.002725630.0022517560.003261544
547.8330138 / 65,536647 / 368,128785 / 433,6640.0018101570.0014673940.002202442
5.2548.083064 / 65,536112 / 104,448176 / 169,9840.0010353920.00065741350.001536053
5.548.333038 / 65,536154 / 225,792192 / 291,3280.0006590510.00042550370.0009654754
5.7548.583028 / 65,536124 / 333,824152 / 399,3600.0003806090.00023110240.0005838066
648.833013 / 65,536188 / 815,616201 / 881,1520.00022811050.00014766940.0003335035
6.2549.08308 / 65,536179 / 1,388,288187 / 1,453,8240.00012862638.154744e-050.0001910581
6.549.33302 / 65,53611 / 196,60813 / 262,1444.959106e-056.055558e-060.000172009
6.7549.58304 / 65,5369 / 196,60813 / 262,1444.959106e-056.055558e-060.000172009
749.83301 / 65,5364 / 196,6085 / 262,1441.907349e-052.945894e-070.0001139246
7.2550.08302 / 65,5360 / 196,6082 / 262,1447.629395e-069.694379e-108.700967e-05
7.550.33300 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05
7.7550.58301 / 65,5361 / 196,6082 / 262,1447.629395e-069.694379e-108.700967e-05
850.83300 / 65,5362 / 196,6082 / 262,1447.629395e-069.694379e-108.700967e-05

R2 / C1 / I=1 / Doppler

4188 air symbols; nominal duration 0.218125 s (waveform guards excluded).
Es/N0 [dB]C/N0 [dB-Hz]Original k / nAdded k / nTotal k / nFERLowerUpper
042.833065,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.2543.083065,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.543.333065,510 / 65,5360 / 065,510 / 65,5360.99960330.99900710.9998938
0.7543.583064,679 / 65,5360 / 064,679 / 65,5360.98692320.98432140.9892235
143.833058,811 / 65,5360 / 058,811 / 65,5360.89738460.890720.9038031
1.2544.083043,106 / 65,5360 / 043,106 / 65,5360.65774540.64746930.6679236
1.544.333024,819 / 65,5360 / 024,819 / 65,5360.37870790.36828980.3892011
1.7544.583014,381 / 65,5360 / 014,381 / 65,5360.21943660.21060250.2284446
244.83309,773 / 65,5360 / 09,773 / 65,5360.14912410.14155430.1569114
2.2545.08307,262 / 65,5360 / 07,262 / 65,5360.11080930.10416330.1176965
2.545.33305,305 / 65,5360 / 05,305 / 65,5360.080947880.075197720.08695764
2.7545.58303,909 / 65,5360 / 03,909 / 65,5360.059646610.05467720.06488882
345.83302,876 / 65,5360 / 02,876 / 65,5360.043884280.039609140.04844197
3.2546.08302,078 / 65,5360 / 02,078 / 65,5360.031707760.028074520.03563109
3.546.33301,375 / 65,5360 / 01,375 / 65,5360.020980830.018038140.02422024
3.7546.5830965 / 65,5360 / 0965 / 65,5360.014724730.012276550.01747346
446.8330671 / 65,536185 / 18,432856 / 83,9680.010194360.0083911560.01223625
4.2547.0830420 / 65,536476 / 71,168896 / 136,7040.0065543070.0054093580.007849308
4.547.3330291 / 65,536572 / 134,656863 / 200,1920.0043108620.0035393920.005186521
4.7547.5830186 / 65,536658 / 252,928844 / 318,4640.0026502210.0021673760.003199748
547.8330119 / 65,536741 / 439,808860 / 505,3440.0017018110.0013922830.002054049
5.2548.083063 / 65,536100 / 107,264163 / 172,8000.0009432870.00058747450.00141985
5.548.333046 / 65,536101 / 173,568147 / 239,1040.00061479520.0003715540.0009462414
5.7548.583024 / 65,536150 / 402,688174 / 468,2240.0003716170.00023341990.0005558485
648.833021 / 65,536100 / 471,808121 / 537,3440.00022518160.00012763890.0003629829
6.2549.08306 / 65,53616 / 196,60822 / 262,1448.392334e-051.871073e-050.0002288403
6.549.33303 / 65,53613 / 196,60816 / 262,1446.103516e-059.734967e-060.0001915902
6.7549.58304 / 65,5364 / 196,6088 / 262,1443.051758e-051.616854e-060.0001371213
749.83300 / 65,5367 / 196,6087 / 262,1442.670288e-051.049991e-060.000129647
7.2550.08302 / 65,5360 / 196,6082 / 262,1447.629395e-069.694379e-108.700967e-05
7.550.33300 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05
7.7550.58300 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05
850.83300 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05

R2 / C1 / I=1 / Doppler + jitter + echo

4188 air symbols; nominal duration 0.218125 s (waveform guards excluded).
Es/N0 [dB]C/N0 [dB-Hz]Original k / nAdded k / nTotal k / nFERLowerUpper
042.833065,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.2543.083065,536 / 65,5360 / 065,536 / 65,53610.99976241
0.543.333065,506 / 65,5360 / 065,506 / 65,5360.99954220.9989150.9998634
0.7543.583064,786 / 65,5360 / 064,786 / 65,5360.98855590.98610950.9906998
143.833059,232 / 65,5360 / 059,232 / 65,5360.90380860.89732730.9100397
1.2544.083043,371 / 65,5360 / 043,371 / 65,5360.66178890.65154110.6719366
1.544.333025,274 / 65,5360 / 025,274 / 65,5360.38565060.37519410.396178
1.7544.583014,789 / 65,5360 / 014,789 / 65,5360.22566220.21673660.2347578
244.83309,979 / 65,5360 / 09,979 / 65,5360.15226750.14463050.1601198
2.2545.08307,443 / 65,5360 / 07,443 / 65,5360.11357120.10685120.1205306
2.545.33305,386 / 65,5360 / 05,386 / 65,5360.082183840.076392580.08823394
2.7545.58304,040 / 65,5360 / 04,040 / 65,5360.061645510.056596190.06696639
345.83302,836 / 65,5360 / 02,836 / 65,5360.043273930.039028380.0478024
3.2546.08302,037 / 65,5360 / 02,037 / 65,5360.031082150.027485320.03496946
3.546.33301,444 / 65,5360 / 01,444 / 65,5360.022033690.019015860.02534758
3.7546.5830949 / 65,5360 / 0949 / 65,5360.014480590.012053760.01720812
446.8330677 / 65,536195 / 17,664872 / 83,2000.010480770.008643380.01255884
4.2547.0830453 / 65,536414 / 60,928867 / 126,4640.0068557060.0056410980.008232009
4.547.3330320 / 65,536472 / 115,968792 / 181,5040.004363540.0035519220.005289702
4.7547.5830208 / 65,536626 / 218,112834 / 283,6480.0029402640.0024025610.003552518
547.8330110 / 65,536894 / 482,5601,004 / 548,0960.0018317960.0015215620.002181498
5.2548.083065 / 65,536112 / 101,888177 / 167,4240.0010571960.0006722680.001566619
5.548.333034 / 65,536163 / 261,120197 / 326,6560.00060308090.00039137880.0008800215
5.7548.583027 / 65,536160 / 348,928187 / 414,4640.00045118510.00028871810.0006654614
648.833010 / 65,536250 / 1,089,536260 / 1,155,0720.00022509420.00015382830.0003155585
6.2549.083010 / 65,536137 / 1,089,536147 / 1,155,0720.00012726487.588184e-050.0001978292
6.549.33305 / 65,53612 / 196,60817 / 262,1446.484985e-051.109497e-050.0001979558
6.7549.58302 / 65,5365 / 196,6087 / 262,1442.670288e-051.049991e-060.000129647
749.83302 / 65,5365 / 196,6087 / 262,1442.670288e-051.049991e-060.000129647
7.2550.08301 / 65,5361 / 196,6082 / 262,1447.629395e-069.694379e-108.700967e-05
7.550.33301 / 65,5360 / 196,6081 / 262,1443.814697e-061.64201e-137.611759e-05
7.7550.58300 / 65,5360 / 196,6080 / 262,144006.205515e-05
850.83300 / 65,5361 / 196,6081 / 262,1443.814697e-061.64201e-137.611759e-05